Memory (1913-1914) by Augustus Lukeman, Ida & Isidor Straus Memorial, Straus Park, Manhattan, New York City, ca.1914
| |

Audrey Munson: The First Supermodel

America’s first supermodel was Audrey Munson (1891–1996).

Munson posed for dozens of New York’s best-known statues, and a 1915 newspaper billed her as “the super-favorite model.” She also starred nude in a feature film. Janice Dickinson, who claims she coined “supermodel” in 1979, came sixty years later.

After reaching the height of fame, Munson’s career and her mental health rapidly failed. In 1922 she attempted suicide; in 1931 her mother arranged for her to be placed in a New York state asylum. She remained institutionalized until her death in 1996.
Audrey Munson in a bathing suit and cap, smiling and waving on a beach, holding a parasol

Who Was Audrey Munson?

Munson was the most sought-after artists’ model in America between about 1909 and 1915. She posed for many of the leading sculptors of the day, and her form still stands on monuments across New York City. Sculptors loved her look: tall (5′8″) with long legs and a high brow, prominent cheekbones, and a long neoclassical nose.

Audrey Marie Munson was born on June 8, 1891, in Rochester, New York. Her father moved through a series of jobs: coachman, driver, trolley conductor, real estate agent. Her mother, Katherine “Kittie” Mahaney, was the daughter of Irish immigrants and had worked in the Auburn, NY, woolen mills as a girl.

After the parents divorced, mother and daughter would live together, almost without a break, for the next thirty years.

There was also an alleged prophecy. When Audrey was small, her mother supposedly took her to a fortune-teller, who said she would be famous and then poor, and that men would love her but she would never marry.

Broadway and the Sculptors

Munson first appeared on stage in 1908, with a touring dance act called Gerald Hampton’s Dancing Dolls. In the spring of 1909 she and her mother moved to New York.

Audrey Munson, at left, with fellow chorus girls in wide hats and long skirts hauling bricks by hod and wheelbarrow across a building site, 1909
Audrey Munson at left with fellow chorus girls who won a bet that they could work for a short time as bricklayers; Leslie’s Illustrated Weekly, October 28, 1909; modified from the original

Her Broadway debut in 1909 was in a musical comedy called The Boy and the Girl, in which she played a footman. That autumn she joined the chorus of The Girl and the Wizard at the Casino Theatre. She was never one of the Ziegfeld Girls, and in later life she denied ever having been a chorus girl at all.

Late in 1909, while she was window-shopping with her mother, a photographer asked whether she had ever modeled. It is thought the man was Felix Benedict Herzog, a photographer with a studio on Broadway. Herzog photographed her, artfully draped, and introduced her to artists.

She came to the attention of sculptor Isidore Konti, who wanted Munson to model for the Three Graces work for the new ballroom of the Hotel Astor.

James Bone, in his biography of Munson (see below), says that Konti declared that Audrey, then 18, must “pose in the altogether”—nude. Munson’s mother was aghast and refused. But after three months (and her daughter’s persistent interest), the matter was settled and the nude posing began.

Munson’s next sitting, according to her serial memoir, was with sculptor Adolph Weinman, whom she took at first for a janitor. He made short work of her shyness: “I don’t want to see your dressmaker’s art. I want to see what nature did for you. Get your clothes off.” The pose she fell into that morning, she says, became one of her most famous statues, Descending Night (see below).

The pay was fifty cents an hour, the standard studio rate. She says her income never went over thirty dollars a week in her first two years, and hardly ever topped thirty-five after that. But she worked steadily, posing for what she claimed were two hundred artists.

Miss Manhattan

Beaux-Arts sculptors were filling New York with civic allegory in the 1910s, and many of them regarded Munson as the perfect model.

Civic Fame, Adolph A. Weinman’s gilded statue modeled on Audrey Munson, holding a shield and a turreted crown atop the Manhattan Municipal Building
Civic Fame, by Adolph Alexander Weinman

Adolph Weinman modeled the gilded Civic Fame on top of the Municipal Building from Munson. She wears a laurel wreath and holds aloft a crown whose five turrets represent the five boroughs of New York City.

Daniel Chester French used her for the granite figures of Manhattan and Brooklyn that stood before the Manhattan Bridge and are now outside the Brooklyn Museum. Attilio Piccirilli carved her as the central figure of the Maine Monument at Columbus Circle and as both grieving women of the Firemen’s Memorial on Riverside Drive. Augustus Lukeman made her the bronze Memory of the Straus Memorial at 106th Street (see the image at the top of the post).

The serial memoir is full of what the sculptors allegedly said to her. Karl Bitter sent her home to pick up a marble with her toes, “two hundred times with each foot,” to improve their shape. Salvatore Cartaino Scarpitta, admiring the dimples in her back, warned her: “if ever you see them going—cut out the apple pie.”

In June 1913 the New York Sun announced that all New York bowed to “the real Miss Manhattan,” and the papers took to calling her “the most copied girl in America.”

A fuller set of works that can be connected to her is in my gallery of Audrey Munson statues, and photographs of her are in a companion gallery of Audrey Munson photos.

The Exposition Girl

The peak of Munson’s fame came in 1915.

Descending Night, a bronze cast of Adolph A. Weinman’s figure modeled on Audrey Munson: a nude winged woman, head bowed, arms raised to her face
Descending Night (bronze copy), Adolph A. Weinman

The Panama-Pacific International Exposition in San Francisco drew some nineteen million visitors. The Exposition included many sculpted statues, and an estimated three-quarters of them were based on Munson.  Her form was so common at the show she was dubbed “the Exposition Girl.”

Weinman’s Descending Night topped a column at the fair, and there were many copies of Alexander Stirling Calder’s Star Maiden.

She says Attilio Piccirilli’s Exposition figure Rain was built from two women: the young Mabel Normand, then a fifty-cents-an-hour model, “for the body, me for the face.”

She tried to turn the fame into a stage career. In April 1915 she opened at the Palace Theatre in a vaudeville revue, The Fashion Show, billed as the Spirit of Fashion. She was dropped a week into the three-week run.

Audrey Munson Movies: Purity and Inspiration

Munson was cast in several films. The Thanhouser company cast her as an artist’s model in Inspiration, released in November 1915. She appeared nude in the film.

Audrey Munson posing nude on a model’s stand, arms raised, between two men in an artist’s studio, in a still from the 1915 film Inspiration
Audrey Munson as an artist’s model in the 1915 film Inspiration

The film caused a sensation. She was one of the first leading ladies to appear nude; Bone calls her “America’s first naked movie star.” While the picture packed theaters, it was ordered removed from some, and a theater owner in Ossining, NY, was arrested for showing it. No copy survives.

Munson’s next film, Purity, followed in 1916. She plays the title character, a young woman in love with a poor poet. Through a series of circumstances she agrees to pose nude for a painter who gives her money that she uses to publish the poet’s works.

Censors demanded cuts and some jurisdictions banned it, but it drew crowds. It is the only one of her films that survives.

A third Munson picture, The Girl o’ Dreams, was shot on Catalina Island that summer but apparently never released.

Her private life also made the news with stories that she had secretly married Hermann Oelrichs Jr., heir to a silver fortune. They apparently had a close relationship around 1917, but there is no record of a marriage.

The Wilkins Murder

On the night of February 27, 1919, Julia Wilkins was beaten to death. Her husband, Dr. Walter Keene Wilkins, blamed burglars but was soon charged with the murder.

Munson and her mother had rented rooms in the Wilkinses’ house on West 65th Street in Manhattan, leaving a few weeks before the killing. Wilkins had apparently killed his wife so that he could marry Audrey, although she claimed to have had no awareness of the plan.

The newspapers had a field day speculating that she was, in fact, in cahoots with the doctor. Wilkins was convicted in June and took his own life in jail before he could be moved to Sing Sing penitentiary. Munson was never officially accused of anything, but the damage was done. Her career was in ruins.

The Serial Memoir and Heedless Moths

By 1920 she and her mother were living in poverty, with Audrey said to be working as a waitress in a diner.

Hand-colored lantern slide advertising Heedless Moths: “Equity Pictures present America’s most perfect, most beautiful, most versatile artist’s model Audrey Munson”
Lantern slide for Heedless Moths, Munson’s final film

In 1921, the newspaper chain owned by William Randolph Hearst ran a twenty-part memoir under her byline, “The Queen of the Artists’ Studios,” to a combined readership of about  thirty million. (Twenty years later Hearst did the same for Mary Nolan, in the 1941 “Bubbles” Wilson memoir.)

The serial is transcribed in full in my edition of the Audrey Munson memoir. It is part of my collection of Jazz Age primary sources, transcribed in full.

In his biography, Bone says the serial was ghostwritten by Henry Leyford Gates, an editor at the Hearst New York paper.

The serial also publicized Munson for a film, Heedless Moths, produced by Perry Plays. Munson’s name was on the film publicity, but Jane Thomas played her part, and Munson appeared only in a few posing scenes. A much-advertised check to her for $27,500 was never paid; she later called it a forgery. No copy of the film is known to survive.

What Did Munson Say About Modeling?

The serial memoir is the fullest account of modeling by anyone who worked in it during the era, and it shows how little she resembled the supermodels who came later. She thought the model got no credit at all: an actress or even a chorus girl is praised in the reviews, but “Not so with the artists’ model. She remains ever anonymous.”

She looked down on the branches of modeling that would produce real celebrities. The fashion mannequin, she wrote, had it easy: “The life of a maniquin [sic], as the animated feminine clothes-horses are called, must be very delightful.” Photography she held at arm’s length: “it may happen that some day photographers will prove themselves worthy of the designation ‘artist.’” She had no use for modern art either. The Cubists were “just crazy persons capitalizing their insanities.”

She learned that pay sorted models into two kinds. A celebrated California painter, hiring her to pose as Lady Godiva, opened with a question she didn’t understand: “To some of my models I pay the usual five dollars a day—to others I pay five dollars an hour. Which do you expect?” Her puzzlement was the right answer. The hourly models, Munson makes clear through heavy euphemism, were women who made their real money as rich men’s mistresses. The painter paid their price but never let them cross “the line that divides the home from the workshop.” The day-rate models ate lunch with his wife and daughter. After a few days, so did she. And she knew how a model’s career ended. The artist’s verdict comes first gently, then plainly: “Nothing at all for you; your form is getting too flabby. Don’t bother me again.”

Munson’s Search for “The Perfect Man”

Short on funds, Munson and her mother moved north of Syracuse, NY, near a small village named Mexico. In 1921 she staged a newspaper search for a “perfect man” to marry, and in April 1922 she announced her engagement to an aviator whom the New York Times could not find. On May 27, 1922, at the house she shared with her mother in Mexico, she attempted suicide by swallowing poison.

For the rest of the decade she lived as an eccentric recluse. She nursed grudges and delusions tied to various wrongs she believed she had suffered during her film career.

St. Lawrence State Hospital

On June 8, 1931, her fortieth birthday, Munson’s mother petitioned a court to have her daughter committed to a state asylum for the insane, St. Lawrence State Hospital at Ogdensburg, NY. Two local doctors certified her. The court papers give no diagnosis, though the symptoms suggest schizophrenia.

She stayed at Ogdensburg for almost sixty-five years. Her mother, the last visitor for decades, died in 1958. In November 1984 her half-niece discovered that her famous aunt was still alive and visited with her.

Audrey Munson died at the hospital on February 20, 1996, at the age of 104. There was no headstone of her own until 2016, when, according to Wikipedia, one was dedicated on what would have been her 125th birthday.

The newspapers had once called her the most copied girl in America. By the time she died, hardly anyone remembered her name, much less associated her with the dozens of statues still on view in New York City.

Common Questions

Was Janice Dickinson the First Supermodel?

No. Dickinson says she coined the word around 1979, but “super model” was in print by the 1940s, and Twiggy was called a “supermodel” in 1967. Audrey Munson was famous by name for modeling more than sixty years before Dickinson. James Bone makes the full case in The Curse of Beauty: The Scandalous & Tragic Life of Audrey Munson, America’s First Supermodel (2016).

When Was the Word “Supermodel” First Used?

Earlier than most people think. The painter Henry Stacy Marks joked about a “‘super’ model” in The Strand Magazine in 1891. In the 1940s newspapers used “super-model” for a type of fashion model; Cosmopolitan applied “super model” to a named woman, Anita Colby, in 1949; and Playboy called Twiggy a “London supermodel” in June 1967. Munson’s 1915 billing as “the super-favorite model” came decades before any of them used the word for a particular woman.

Is “Heedless Moths” a Lost Film?

Yes. No copy is held by any film archive. The 1921 serial is now the fullest surviving version of the story the picture was built from.

How Much Did Artists’ Models Get Paid?

Fifty cents an hour was the standard studio rate in New York in the early 1910s, paid to beginners and to the most sought-after model in the country alike. In the serial she says her income never went over $30 a week in her first two years, working every day with a full order book, and that a week’s pay hardly ever topped $35 after that.

Is Everything in the Serial True?

No. The verifiable parts—the sculpture, the commissions, the pay rates—hold up well. The unverifiable parts are concentrated in the dramatic private anecdotes, and at least one of them, the opening story of a painter forcing Munson to pose under a waterfall at gunpoint, names an artist and a painting that are unknown. The edition transcribes what the paper printed; it does not vouch for it.

Did Audrey Munson Write the Serial Herself?

Unclear. The byline and the paper’s own introduction say she did. James Bone’s 2016 biography says the Hearst newspaperman Henry Leyford Gates ghostwrote it; the court papers Bone cites document Gates as the writer of the film made from the serial, and as holder of a third of its rights, but do not name him as author of the articles. Andrea Geyer, who located ten of the twenty installments in 2004–08, treats the writing as Munson’s own, though her work predates the claim. The likeliest answer is the ordinary one for this kind of Hearst serial: her material, someone else’s sentences.